La Michoacana Plus vs Premium and Which Menu Fits You

Abraham Doe

La Michoacana Plus versus Premium: Plus began around 2017 and Premium has 56 stores

This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

La Michoacana Premium is built around paletas, nieves and traditional antojitos, while La Michoacana Plus puts more weight on drinks, waffles, pancakes and loaded fruit cups.

Premium has 56 stores in 8 states, and the Plus concept grew out of Chula Vista, California, around 2017, so both are chains with owners who run each shop on their own.

If you want ice cream and paletas in a wide variety of flavors, I recommend you go to a Premium.

If you want a snack, a drink and a novelty dessert in the same visit, a Plus will give you more to choose from.

Where each one started

Premium’s story starts in Tocumbo, Michoacán, the town known as the land of the paleta, where local sellers carried paletas and nieves to nearby towns in the late 1930s and 1940s.

The US shops grew from a franchise started by Marco Andrade in 2008, with the first shop in Aurora, Illinois, and the slogan printed on its sticks is “If it’s not premium, it’s not Michoacana.”

Plus came later in 2017, and the brand presents itself as more than 40 years in the paleta business with a third generation of paleteros.

La Michoacana Plus vs Premium compared

CategoryLa Michoacana PremiumLa Michoacana Plus
Stores56 in CA, IL, AZ, CO, NM, TN, TX and WIShops in California, Texas, Oklahoma, Illinois and Mississippi, no count published
Core menuPaletas (water and cream), nieves, mangonadas, aguas frescas, fruta preparada, antojitosPaletas, nieves, bionicos and fruit, mangonadas, esquites, tostilocos, michelaguas, raspados
ExtrasTortas, gazpacho cups, fresh juices at some shopsWaffles, mini pancakes, crazy shakes, churros, floating waters, Lucha Frutos
FlavorsDozens, with 40-plus paletas made in-house at the Pilsen shop in ChicagoNo chain-wide number published
FranchiseInquiries by email, offers made only through a Franchise Disclosure DocumentA franchise page invites applicants, no fees listed

Premium’s menu is organized around frozen treats first, with a few savory items, while Plus builds out a whole second menu of drinks and sweets.

In practice, that means a Premium is the better stop for a scoop or a stick, and a Plus is the better stop for a group where everyone wants something different.

What you will actually order at each

At a Premium, the usual order is a paleta, a scoop in a cone or waffle bowl, or a mangonada.

The scoops come in water or cream versions and can be bought by the cup, cone, waffle or even by the liter, and at one Illinois shop a single scoop was $4.50, a double was $7.60 and a triple was $9.20.

At a Plus, you will see more of the loaded and trendy items.

A Lucha Frutos is a fruit cup stacked with chamoy, Tajín and lime over fresh-cut mango, watermelon and pineapple, and the menu also includes michelaguas, which are fruit drinks, plus aguas flotantes, raspados, churros and mini pancakes.

Summer menus add seasonal specials on top of that.

You can see the price ranges for items on both sides in the La Michoacana menu with prices, and for drinks and snacks the numbers come mostly from Plus-style menus.

Does the store matter more than the name

Flavors, products and prices vary from one Premium store to the next, and the same goes for Plus, since each shop belongs to a different owner.

A Premium in Modesto can feel very different from one in Chicago, so a single bad review of one shop tells you little about the brand.

So before you commit, look at the specific shop’s menu photos. If the flavor list is long and the case is full, you’re probably in a good one, and if the menu is short or hard to find, you might want to try a different location.

Tip: Read the sign and the menu before you assume which chain you’re in, because lookalike names such as Premier, Superior, Gourmet and Deluxe exist, and they are separate businesses from Premium and Plus.

Which one to pick

  • Pick Premium if: you want the widest paleta and nieve case, you like tortas or fruit cups, and you plan to buy ice cream by the scoop or by the liter.
  • Pick Plus if: you want drinks, waffles, pancakes or loaded fruit cups, and you’re going with people who each want something different.
  • Pick whichever is closer if: you just want a mangonada or a paleta, since both sell them and the shop’s own recipe matters more than the chain.

If you are weighing either of these against a smaller independent shop, I explain that in the La Michoacana Plus vs La Michoacana guide.

What to check before you drive to either

Neither name guarantees the same menu at every door, so a two-minute check saves a wasted trip.

Open the shop’s delivery listing and look at the photos, because that shows whether the case is full of paletas or the board is full of drinks.

Then check the hours, since a Premium may open at 8 a.m. while a Plus may open at 11, and see the La Michoacana hours guide for real examples.

Prices are the third check. Both chains sell the same kinds of items, such as paletas, mangonadas and fruit cups, but each shop sets its own prices, so a cup at one can cost $3 or $4 more than the same size at the other.

The ranges for every size are in the mangonada price guide, which helps you tell if a shop is charging more than normal.

FAQ

Which one has more paleta flavors?

Premium, since the Pilsen shop alone makes more than 40 paleta flavors in-house.

Plus doesn’t publish a count I could confirm. You can browse the types of flavors in the La Michoacana paleta flavors list.

Are Plus and Premium owned by the same company?

They have separate websites, separate franchise pages and different menus, so treat them as two different brands that happen to share the Michoacana name.

Can I order delivery from both?

Yes, both show up on delivery apps in many areas.

The menu prices there are set by each shop and can be higher than at the counter, so check the shop before you decide.

Leave a Comment