La Michoacana Paleta Flavors List With Water and Cream Options

Abraham Doe

Updated on:

La Michoacana paleta flavors: a full case holds 30 to 40 flavors in water and cream families

This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

A full La Michoacana paleta case has 30 to 40 flavors, and they split into two families: paletas de agua (water-based fruit) and paletas de leche or crema (cream-based and dessert flavors).

I confirmed that one shop has 35 flavors in its menu, and Premium shops make dozens in-house, with the Pilsen shop in Chicago counting more than 40.

Because every shop is run by its own owner, you won’t match the list below exactly.

Use it to know what to look for, and ask the person behind the counter which ones were made that week.

Water-based fruit paletas

These are made with fruit or juice and sugar, with no milk, and they are the lighter, more refreshing side of the case.

I sorted the flavors on one 35-flavor menu by how they are usually made, and this side includes:

  • Mango and spicy mango (mango picante)
  • Strawberry (fresa) and strawberry kiwi
  • Kiwi, melon, watermelon and pineapple
  • Lime (limón) and tropical fruits
  • Blackberry (zarzamora), passion fruit and guava (guayaba)
  • Soursop (guanábana) and nance
  • Tamarind (tamarindo) and jamaica, which is made from hibiscus flowers
  • Cucumber with lime and Tajín

Cucumber with lime and Tajín is the one that surprises people, because it tastes sour, salty and a little spicy, and it is nothing like a sweet ice pop.

In the same way, spicy mango and tamarind are the ones to choose when you want something with a bite, while watermelon and melon are the easy picks for hot days.

Cream-based and dessert paletas

This is the side of the case where flavors come from sweets, cookies and cakes, and where the paleta is thick and creamy. The same menu includes:

  • Strawberries and cream, strawberry cheesecake and strawberry banana
  • Coconut (coco), banana and piña colada
  • Vanilla, horchata and pecan (nuez)
  • Oreo, Cookie Monster and Fruity Pebbles
  • Gansito, Ferrero Rocher and birthday cake
  • Cinnamon churro and cotton candy bubble gum

Some flavors can go either way. Coconut, banana, piña colada and strawberry banana are made with milk at one shop and with water at another.

So if you avoid dairy, ask which version is in the case before you pick, because the color alone won’t tell you.

Also, flavors like Oreo, Gansito and Ferrero Rocher use branded cookies, cakes and candy as ingredients, and each of those has its own ingredient list that the shop may not be able to read out to you.

Flavors you will only find at some shops

The less common ones are where a paletería shows what it’s proud of.

Shops in the US have listed chongos (made from curdled milk and cinnamon), pine nut, avocado, chili mango, mamey, cream cheese with fruit and a Mexican-style rice pudding.

And the owner of one Anaheim shop makes pistachio, quince, fig and mazapán from scratch.

If you see a flavor you can’t find anywhere else, that’s usually the one worth trying.

If you’re comparing a shop paleta with the boxed version from the freezer aisle, the grocery lineup is smaller and more predictable.

It includes fresas con crema, coco con crema, mango con crema, mango chamoy, arroz con leche, and minis with chamoy in pineapple, lime, and mango.

Limited editions come and go, like the horchata with strawberry and the piña colada that came out in 2020.

Reading the case at the counter

A paleta case is usually sorted loosely, with the fruit bars together and the cream-based ones in another row.

So you can often tell the families apart by color before you read a label.

The fruit bars look translucent with visible pieces of fruit, while the cream bars are opaque and pale. The chocolate-dipped ones sit apart, since the dip is added after the paleta is made.

Also, the case isn’t fixed. Limited-edition flavors don’t always become permanent, and shops add trending items such as Dubai-style desserts on their own, so a favorite from last month may be gone today.

At one Las Vegas shop, the creamy flavors that sell best are cream cheese with fruit, strawberry and cream, and Oreo cookies and cream, but the best seller at your shop is only the person behind the counter can tell you.

Buying for kids, parties or sharing

For kids, the fruit bars with no spice are the safe choice, because strawberry, watermelon and pineapple melt more slowly and don’t have chile in them.

Tamarind, spicy mango and the cucumber flavor all carry chile or salt, so check before you hand one over.

For a party, ask the shop whether it takes orders by the box, since many do, and pick a mix of one water-based and one cream-based flavor for each guest so nobody is stuck with a flavor they dislike.

If you are feeding a group with allergies, buy from the case on the day, not ahead, because a case that changes weekly can have a flavor you never saw before.

And if you want to taste several, the boxed variety packs at the grocery store are the cheaper way to sample the lineup.

How to choose by taste

  • Sweet and creamy: Fresas con crema, coconut and rice pudding are the classic dessert flavors, and they taste the closest to ice cream.
  • Sour and spicy: Lime, tamarind, spicy mango and cucumber with Tajín are the best fit if you like chili candy.
  • Cold and refreshing: Watermelon, melon, pineapple and cucumber taste the lightest, and they hold up in summer heat.
  • Dessert for a party: Churro, Oreo and Ferrero Rocher paletas look and taste more like a treat, and the shop with that 35-flavor menu prices them the same as a plain fruit one.

Tip: Ask for a chocolate dip if the shop does it, because you pick a paleta, they dip it, and you choose coconut, pecans, peanuts or sprinkles on top, and it turns a regular paleta into something closer to a dessert, though the price goes up, so ask before you order.

Dairy, milk and allergens

Water-based paletas are dairy free by nature, and the boxed chamoy and fruit paletas are labeled dairy free.

However, the cream-based ones contain milk, and one boxed rice pudding paleta states that it was made on equipment shared with peanuts, wheat, tree nuts and milk.

So if you have an allergy, read the label on the box or ask the shop about their equipment, since a fruit paleta at a shop that also sells nut flavors can still be in contact with nuts.

If you want to check ingredients for religious reasons, the guide on whether La Michoacana is halal explains what to ask about the cream-based flavors.

And if you want to know what a stick costs, see my guide on La Michoacana menu prices.

Leave a Comment